Replacement Showers for Greater Milwaukee Homes
A Better Shower Starts With the Right Replacement System
An outdated shower can make your entire bathroom feel harder to use. Cracked surfaces, difficult-to-clean areas, outdated designs, or a shower that no longer fits your needs are all signs it may be time for an upgrade. Exterior Pros installs BCI Acrylic replacement showers for homeowners who want showers that are easier to maintain.
Along with being easy to maintain, our shower systems are designed for long-term durability and have a cleaner look. Every installation is a complete replacement performed by our in-house bath crews. We remove the existing shower system and install a new BCI Acrylic shower designed around your bathroom, giving you a finished space that looks better and works better.
Why Homeowners Choose BCI Acrylic Showers
Your shower is one of the most frequently used areas of your home, so the materials need to stand up to everyday use without creating extra maintenance. BCI Acrylic shower systems feature a nonporous acrylic surface that helps resist moisture, mold, and mildew. The smooth surface is easier to clean than grout-heavy options and does not require sealing or specialized maintenance products.
Additional benefits include:
Low-maintenance surfaces: Spend less time scrubbing and more time enjoying your bathroom.
Long-lasting durability: Designed to resist fading, discoloration, cracking, bubbling, and peeling.
Custom-fit installation: Systems are configured around your bathroom rather than forced into a standard size.
A cleaner appearance: Updated walls, fixtures, and finishes create a fresh look without a full bathroom remodel.
Shower Replacement Options From Exterior Pros
Every bathroom has different needs. Whether you’re replacing an aging shower, updating the look of the space, or making it easier to access, we can help you choose the right configuration.
Standard Shower Replacement
A standard shower replacement removes your existing shower system and replaces it with a new BCI Acrylic unit. We complete full replacements only, so you’re not left with old materials underneath or temporary fixes that need attention later.
Tub-to-Shower Conversion
If your bathtub no longer fits your lifestyle, a tub-to-shower conversion can replace it with a walk-in shower designed for your existing bathroom layout.
Easy-Access Shower Replacement
For homeowners looking for a safer and more accessible shower, we offer low-barrier and ADA-compliant configurations. Learn more about our easy-access bathroom options.
What to Expect During Shower Replacement
A lasting shower replacement starts with what's behind the finished surface. Instead of treating an aging shower as a cosmetic issue, we remove the old system so we can install the new shower on a properly prepared foundation.
Here's what the process typically involves:
Remove the Existing Shower
We remove the old shower surround, base, and necessary underlying materials.
Prepare the Space
We inspect and prepare the exposed area for the new system.
Install Your BCI Acrylic Shower
We install the shower base, wall system, and selected components according to manufacturer guidelines.
Complete the Finishing Work
Our crew checks the fit, seals, and finished details before cleaning the work area.
Design a Shower That Fits Your Home
A replacement shower should not only perform well; it should also look like it belongs in your bathroom. BCI Acrylic systems offer options to help you create a finished shower that fits your preferences, including:
Colors and Finishes: Choose a look that complements the rest of your bathroom.
Shower Sizes and Layouts: Fit the new system to your existing space.
Fixtures and Hardware: Select features that work for your routine.
Storage Options: Add built-in shelving and accessories for everyday convenience.
Instead of sorting through endless product choices, we provide high-quality BCI Acrylic options to make the selection process easier.
What to Expect From Your Shower Installation
Replacing a shower should be stress-free throughout the installation process. Exterior Pros uses in-house bath crews for our shower replacements, and we assign a dedicated project manager to each project. You will have a consistent point of contact throughout the process and a team that understands the product being installed.
The process begins with a free estimate. We’ll look at your current shower, discuss what you want to change, and explain your options. Once you receive your estimate, your quoted pricing stays valid for a full year, giving you time to make your decision. Financing options are available for qualifying homeowners through our lending partners.
Warranty Protection You Can Count On
A new shower is an investment in your home, and strong warranty coverage adds confidence to your decision. BCI Acrylic provides a lifetime warranty covering the shower surface against fading, discoloring, cracking, bubbling, and peeling for as long as you own and live in the home.
If you sell your home within two years of installation, qualifying BCI Acrylic warranty coverage can transfer to the next homeowner. Exterior Pros also provides a 10-year workmanship warranty on qualifying installations. BCI covers the shower system, and we stand behind the quality of the installation itself. Learn more about coverage on our warranties page.
Why You Should Get a Shower Replacement From Us
Exterior Pros has helped Greater Milwaukee homeowners update their homes since 2012. Founder Sheila Hibl started the company after seeing firsthand how difficult it could be for homeowners to find reliable contractors, and that customer-first mindset still guides our work today.
When you choose Exterior Pros, you get:
In-house bath installation crews
Dedicated project managers
BCI Acrylic shower systems
Free estimates with pricing valid for one year
10-year workmanship warranty
A+ Better Business Bureau rating maintained for more than a decade
10 Angi Super Service Awards
We’re based in Sussex and serve homeowners throughout Greater Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin. Read more about our story, see customer experiences on our reviews page, or explore our awards and accolades.
Replacement Showers Throughout Greater Milwaukee
Exterior Pros installs replacement showers throughout the Milwaukee Metro, surrounding suburbs, and Southeast Wisconsin.
We regularly serve homeowners in communities including Sussex, Brookfield, Menomonee Falls, Waukesha, New Berlin, Pewaukee, Elm Grove, Delafield, Wauwatosa, Muskego, and nearby areas. View our service areas for the full list of communities we serve.
Frequently Asked Questions About Replacement Showers
A shower replacement includes removing your existing shower system and installing a new BCI Acrylic shower. We perform complete replacements rather than repairs, overlays, or temporary updates.
BCI Acrylic offers durable, low-maintenance shower systems with nonporous surfaces that resist moisture, mold, and mildew. The material is designed for everyday use while making cleaning easier.
BCI Acrylic systems are built for long-term performance and backed by a Lifetime Warranty covering the shower surface for as long as you own and live in the home.
Yes. A shower replacement focuses on the bathing area, letting you update one of the most-used parts of your bathroom without a full renovation.
Yes. Exterior Pros offers easy-access shower configurations, including ADA-compliant options for homeowners who need improved safety and easier entry.
Yes. Financing options are available through our lending partners for qualifying homeowners.
Start with a free estimate from Exterior Pros. We will evaluate your current shower, discuss your goals, and provide pricing that remains valid for one full year.
Our Baths Project Gallery
What You Can Expect From Exterior Pros
Exterior Pros was built around a simple idea: homeowners should not have to chase down their contractor for answers or wonder whether corners were cut after the project is finished.
That customer-first approach shows up in practical ways throughout your project:
A dedicated project manager
You have a specific point of contact who can answer questions and keep you informed.
Professional crews
Our window and bath installations are completed by full-time crews who work with these products every day.
You can learn more about the standards behind our first-class care and no cut corners approach, or visit Why Us for a closer look at what makes our team different.
0% Interest Financing Available
Exterior Pros offers flexible financing options to make funding your home improvement project easier. We’ll help connect you with our trusted lending partners who offer an easy application and fast approvals. Plus, they offer ZERO interest options if paid in full within 12 months.
See What Greater Milwaukee Customers Are Saying About Our Home Remodeling Services
“They were really helpful and made sure that we were getting the product. They had to custom make our door and they did custom trim work to make sure that everything fits and seals properly. From sales to installation the entire company was helpful and took care of our concerns.”
Melissa J
“Exterior Pros is an Excellent Company to work with! Highly recommend!! Stress free from start to finish. Storm door and window turned out better than we could have imagined. Will definitely use them in the future.”
Nicole S.
“The very helpful staff at Exterior Pros who answered all my questions and gave great ideas when choosing a new patio door as well as storm door. quickly returned all my calls with questions.”
Karen S.
“Working with Exterior Pros was incredibly easy. They never did anything that made me feel less than or stupid, like other companies have. When it came to knowledge of the windows, they were very educational and easy to get in touch with. Their technicians were super helpful, friendly, and knowledgeable.”
Jason R.
“I applaud Exterior Pros for a window job well done! All of our main and second floor windows were replaced at a reasonable price and have enhanced the curb appeal of our home as well as the heating and cooling costs. Thank you Juan, for putting together a great package.”
Sam W.
“If you're looking for a roofer who truly cares about the job, look no further than this family-owned business in Sussex, WI. They take great pride in their work and value each customer. They specialize in providing custom roofing solutions tailored to your unique needs.”
Payton T.
“We love our 22 updated windows ! Note the Prairie Style border we added to front of the home windows. No more bugs sneaking in nor bees through the one rotting window ledge. The guys were awesome and impeccable.”
Penny C.
“Exterior Pros did a great job on my house. They replaced the siding 2 years ago and now replaced the fascia and soffits and a portion of the gutter and gutter guard. They also tore off a wooden awning that was over my patio. The awning was rotting.”
Marcia B.
Contact Us
Mon - Fri: 8:00am - 8:00pm
Sat: 9:00am - 5:00pm
Sun: Closed